Lap Infant or Separate Seat? What Has Worked for Our Family

Before travelling with a baby, the question of whether to book a separate seat can feel like one more major decision added to an already long list.

For us, though, the answer has been fairly straightforward: while our child is young enough to travel as a lap infant, that is generally what we do. Once he turns two and the airline requires his own seat, we book one.

That does not mean I think travelling with a lap infant is automatically the right choice for every family. Transport Canada allows children under two to be held by an accompanying adult, but recommends using an approved child-restraint system in a separate seat for all stages of the flight because it provides better protection during turbulence or an emergency. This is our family’s experience, not a safety recommendation.

What has made the lap-infant option workable for us has less to do with a perfect packing list and more to do with knowing our child, keeping our expectations realistic and being willing to adjust as we go.

We Started With a Shorter Flight

Before taking Pierce on a long-haul journey, we started with flights of approximately four to five hours (which is why we went to Banff as our first family trip).

I think of those first flights as a test, although not in the sense that a child either passes or fails. They gave us a chance to see how he responded to the airport, the airplane, the change in routine and several hours in a confined space. They also gave us a chance to see how we responded.

Flying with a young child is not only about the child’s temperament. It also depends on how comfortable the adults are with disrupted naps, spilled snacks, extra screen time and plans that may need to change without warning.

Our approach has always been to keep the day as relaxed as possible. We do not expect travel days to look like ordinary days at home, and we do not try to enforce every normal rule while sitting in an airplane seat.

After those shorter flights went well, we felt more comfortable attempting longer trips. Pierce has now travelled as a lap infant on shorter North American flights, flights of approximately five hours, overnight long-haul flights and an 18-hour journey to Asia.

Starting small did not guarantee that every future flight would go smoothly. It simply gave us useful information before committing to something much longer.

The Child Matters More Than the Strategy

Pierce has generally adapted well to travel. He is comfortable with changes in routine, can settle when he becomes tired and usually accepts that the day may unfold differently than it does at home. That has made a significant difference.

I could list everything we bring and every choice we make, but the truth is that another child could respond completely differently to the same flight and the same preparation. His younger brother, Harrison, may be just as comfortable travelling or he may require an entirely different approach. We will not know until we begin travelling with him.

That is why I am wary of advice that suggests a particular toy, schedule or seating arrangement will make flying easy for every family. Some children are happy to sit on a parent’s lap for hours. Others want to move constantly, dislike being confined or struggle when they are overtired.

The lap-infant option can save a considerable amount of money, particularly on international flights, but it is only useful when the arrangement is manageable for the child and adults involved.

We Prefer Overnight Flights

Whenever the schedule makes sense, we choose an overnight flight. This does not mean Pierce sleeps perfectly from takeoff to landing. An airplane is still an unfamiliar environment with lights, announcements, meal service and people moving through the cabin. However, an overnight departure gives us a better chance of having at least part of the flight overlap with his usual sleep period.

We let him walk through the airport before boarding rather than keeping him strapped into a stroller unnecessarily. The goal is not to exhaust him to the point of becoming overtired. We simply give him space to move before asking him to sit for several hours.

Once we board, we settle in and allow the flight to unfold. We do not build the entire plan around an exact sleep time because that would add pressure to an already unpredictable day.

We Bring Entertainment, but We Do Not Overpack It

We travel as lightly as we reasonably can, including with what we bring into the cabin. For Pierce, books that invite him to search for things have worked well. I Spy, Where’s Waldo? and similar books keep his attention longer than a story we read once and put away.

We also bring a few compact activities and plenty of snacks. Snacks serve several purposes: they keep him occupied, give him something familiar and help break a long flight into smaller stretches of time.

What we do not bring is an entire toy room.More activities create more luggage, more pieces to lose and more things to manage in a small space. We would rather bring a few familiar options and use them well.

We Do Not Avoid Screen Time

We use screens on flights.

I do not see a long travel day as the place to prove that we can entertain a child without them. Books, conversation, food and activities all have their place, but so does a downloaded show when everyone needs a quieter stretch. Our goal is not to maintain a flawless routine at 35,000 feet. It is to arrive with everyone reasonably calm.

Screen time also works for Pierce because he can stop when he becomes tired or when it is time to move on. He does not usually become distressed when the screen is put away.

That may not be true for every child. For some families, introducing a screen can make the transition away from it harder. Again, this is where knowing your own child matters more than following someone else’s travel rules.

We Choose Our Battles

Travel days already include a lot of unfamiliar expectations for a young child.

They have to move through security, wait at the gate, board when instructed, sit in a limited space and adjust to a completely different schedule. We do not think every ordinary household rule needs to be defended during that process. If an extra snack, another episode or an unusual nap helps the day go more smoothly, we are comfortable with that.

This does not mean there are no boundaries. It means we focus on the ones that matter most: safety, consideration for the people around us and keeping everyone regulated enough to manage the journey.

That relaxed approach is probably part of why travel has worked well for us. Pierce is adaptable, but we try to be adaptable too.

When Would We Buy a Separate Seat Before Age Two?

Although we have generally used the lap-infant option until age two, I would reconsider it if the arrangement stopped feeling manageable.

A separate seat may make more sense when:

A child strongly dislikes being held or wants to move constantly
The adult cannot comfortably hold the child for the length of the flight
The flight is long enough that the additional space would meaningfully improve the journey
The child sleeps better in an approved car seat
One parent will be travelling alone
The family prioritizes using an approved child-restraint system throughout the flight
The cost of the extra seat is manageable within the trip budget

It is also important to understand that purchasing a seat does not automatically make a flight easy. A child may still want to be held, resist the car seat or require frequent attention.

The separate seat provides more space and allows the use of an airline-approved child-restraint system, but it does not remove the need to parent during the flight.

So, Is a Lap Infant or Separate Seat Better?

From a practical and financial perspective, families are still permitted to hold a child under two as a lap infant. Our decision has worked because Pierce has been comfortable with it, we began with manageable flights and we travel with fairly flexible expectations. We keep our cabin luggage light, let him move before boarding, choose overnight flights when possible and use whatever combination of books, snacks, activities, sleep and screens gets us through the journey.

I would not assume that the same approach will automatically work for other toddlers. That may be the most honest answer I can give: the best arrangement is not determined only by a child’s age. It depends on the individual child, the length and timing of the flight, the adults travelling with them, the cost and the family’s comfort with the safety considerations.

We will continue to make the choice based on the child in front of us, not simply what worked the last time.

Life Outside the Inbox